Showing posts with label insurance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label insurance. Show all posts

Sunday, June 07, 2009

Kennedy Tries to Outdo His Own Stereotype

Sen. Ted Kennedy (D-MA) has begun to circulate his new health bill, and its going to be a whopping bill for businesses.

Calling the bill, "American Health Choices Act" or AHCA, which is apparently based on NOT giving employer's any choices as it will force employer's to provide health insurance to employees or "face a penalty."

Why is this a bad idea? It is terrible that people don't have insurance, most personal bankruptcies come from medical care, and, let's face it, the medical/health insurance/prescription drug is busted so why not be support a bill that will increase the coverage of working Americans by putting the burden at the hub of working America, the employer?

Mostly because it won't work (more on that later). But also because the one question I've never heard answered well is, "Why?" Sure the job is place where lots of people go, so if you want to cover a lot of people quickly, that's a great place to start. But again, why is it the employer's responsibility? Ostensibly, the employer pays a wage for work. What the employee does with that money is his or her own decision. If there's not enough wage to cover all that the employee needs then the employee is faced with a hard decision, seek a higher wage or make sacrifices. And you know what? The employer faces hard decisions too. No company can do everything they want with the revenue it earns. So it too must face hard decisions. Hard decisions are OK, that's a part of life. Forcing employer's to bear the health-care burden of their employees using the sole logic of "because they're there" is not only wrong its dumb. Kennedy's proposal just hides the cost of the bill. We'll all wind up paying for it in higher prices or lost jobs, but it will be opaque.

Sure, proponents will use the massive profits of the big companies to show that they can afford health care coverage. Unfortunately, those companies already provide heath insurance for their employees. In order to be effective this bill will have to target small businesses, those same small businesses that struggle with payroll and managing cost's to keep prices competitive. Forcing this on small businesses will absolutely kill them. So this bill will never pass unless it exempts small business.

This inherent flaw will not dawn on anyone in the Legislative branch. So this bill will pass with an exemption for small businesses and nothing will change, and the waste goes on.

Since my daddy raised me to never criticize without a solution, here's mine. Rather than fine/jail/sue the employer into solving a problem of the employee, use the sound base fact that lots of people congregate around work. Allow employee's to ban together to get the best price for their health insurance. Then allow multiple work sites to ban together to get even better pricing. Rather than change the law to force employers to foot the bill, change the law to allow people to use the power of bulk shopping to gain affordable access to health insurance.

But again, can our reader out there (Hi Ma) explain why this is a problem for the employer to solve by force of law?

Wednesday, February 07, 2007

CO Seat-belt bill

CO State Sen. Peter Groff (D-Denver) introduced a bill, SB 151, that would make not wearing a seat-belt a primary traffic offense, meaning a cop could pull you over just for not wearing one (Bonus points to a Democrat for standing in front of this one, way to go Morgan Carroll, D-Aurora, you get the Hydrablog "Who'd a thunk it" Award for breaking stereotypes).

This is a pretty basic Libertarian issue so I won't shed anymore light on this subject. But I do want to take SB 151's proposal and add another one. I did a quick internet search, I'm posting this before I head out the door for a quick trip so forgive my sloppy research, trying to find out if you're auto insurance could be canceled if you weren't wearing a seat-belt, a query if you will. Looks like no. My bet is that because insurance is mandatory, you pretty much get it if you pay for it. What I'm curious about is the impact on seat-belt usage if mandatory laws were repealed, and insurance companies could cancel your policy if you weren't wearing one (I would also expand it to DUI's but lets not complicate things right now).

I think people are smart enough to work through the logic. "If I get into an accident, not only am I much more likely to be injured if I'm not wearing a seat-belt, but not doing so voids my policy. More pain, more expense, no coverage, I'm wearing the thing." Not only that, but my bet is that my rates will go down (and like everything else, this is really all about me), because my rates don't have to cover people who were injured while not wearing said seat-belt. In essence, I'm no loner paying for other people to be stupid.

Also, given that after all these years and laws, compliance is still only at 80%, maybe letting people and insurance companies work it out is best.