Thursday, July 12, 2007

Put Up or Shut Up

The anti-war crowd is thrilled to see more Republicans joining the Bring 'Em Home chorus. Apparently, ending the war is more important than protecting Americans. I make this inflammatory statement because I don't know what the anti-war crowd's solution is to our terrorism problem. I've said it before and I'll say it again - there are good reasons to be opposed to the Iraq war. However, if you don't prop up those reasons with a plan to keep Americans safe after we withdraw from the battlefield, those reasons are irrelevant.

If you claim to be a leader and you can't offer up a solid plan for keeping Americans safe in their homes, on their planes or in their offices then please step aside and let your betters lead. Empty criticism can serve a purpose as it forces all the weaknesses of a choice to be considered. However, that choice should never be abandoned until a clearly superior choice has been identified. This is not a partisan issue, this is life and death. Those abandoning their positions for no reason other than the lack of public support should be ashamed of themselves. Those abandoning because they have found a better solution had best speak up.

1 comment:

McGinty said...

For the war or agin' it, "solution" is too straight-ahead a word for what's to come, whether it's in combat; on foot across our all-but-open borders; 30,000 feet in the air beside guys out of Newark successfully screened for moisturizers instead of pistols; or in one of the billions of shipping crates that inconspicuously arrive annually on our busy shores.

Here then, is a "suggestion" from one citizen to another, and from my lips to lawmakers' ears: Live free and lock and load--wherever, whenever, and legally.

Assume the risk our soldiers do. You had it right after Virginia Tech: Someone armed would have had a shot at saving lives. That's not a solution to terrorism--I say in a free country there ain't one, amigo--but it's a chance, then and now, at your life. Who better to take it?

You're in the protection business. You know safety is a bet, never a sure thing no matter what you're willing to pay. We're paying American soldiers by the thousands into Iraqi dust for the chance that what's left of the country will somehow simultaneously be a terrorist killing floor AND, in the midst of a civil war, a free and prosperous nation. It's a dessert AND a floor wax. But it ain't funny. And it ain't ever gonna work.

Here's what else won't work, at least for what we as a nation are willing at the moment to pay:

*tighter borders;

*increased screening;

*"intel";

*diplomacy;

*this president;

*a new president;

*President Jack Bauer;

*bowing our heads in prayer;

*or, again, putting our heads in the sand and letting our armed forces "do the job" fewer and fewer kids all the time are looking to do.

So do it for them. Get strapped. Whether you "put up or shut up," it's going to be a bumpy ride.