In the process of writing an "I agree" comment to Stalin's entry, I realized that I'm not sure I do. And since unlike Stalin, I'm not a follower, I decided to start a new thread.
Here's the hard part. I do agree with Israel on this one, sort of. I agree in the sense that every nation must protect it's citizens, period. Given today's tools, strategies, thoughts, and environment, they get to invade a state that sponsors terrorist action against them. The question is, is it the right move? For a parallel, I turn to US/Iraq/Afghanistan. If you take the view that we invaded Iraq as a response to the 9/11 attacks, then let's review. 9/11 saw about 3000 US casualties, Iraq (2,539 dead and 39,050 injured)/Afgahanistan (308/924) wars are more costly in that sense. Also, cost to date of the two wars is projected to hit $811 billion. Factor in the severe damage that the Iraq war is causing to US relationships, image, and negotiations, the question is, was it the best path? Furthermore, even if it was, it certainly is not repeatable, something N.Korea figured out early, and Iran and potentially Pakistan have also discovered. So what we do next time? Same for Israel.
Before, I move on, a quick aside. It's the unique nature of terrorism, and state sponsored terrorism, that make it such a difficult problem. Let's imagine Ihateamericaistan is a state sponsor of the stupidjackass terrorism group. The citizens of Ihateamericaistan really have nothing to do with greater US Ihateamericaistan relations, nor do they have any say over what the government does, and in fact, they may be neutral or even like the US. Yet in order to protect US interests, the US invades Ihateamericaistan. The citizens bear the brunt of that attack, and does this turn neutral/favorable Ihateamericaistani's into pro or anti US types, and are they more or less willing to help the terrorists they previously had nothing to do with? This is the dillemma facing Israel. In order to stop state sponsored terrorism, they have to kill/injure lots of civillians, giving the survivors a real reason to hate Israel and help the terrorists, and to continue to support their dictator in his quest to rid the region of Israel. Terrorists may actually do more damage in creating no-win situations for their targets than actual physical damage against them. In its best day, Al Qaeda could not have imagined the damage that their attack caused the US, not in bringing down the towers, but in everything that happened after. I've said in the past this is a conflict about ideals, not land. I'm starting to think that winning it will be mental not physical as well. How do we beat the position they put us in?
So what to do. I don't have a good answer, but I know a crummy situation when I see it, and Israel and the US are in crummy situations. What if the US spent $811 billion in finding a substitute to oil? Taking away the funds that support terrorists, and the political leverage that Iran has because it supplies a crucial part of our lives may help. Not only would it starve Iran of the funds to support terrorsts and keep its citizens at bay, but it would free the US to act without fear of losing the economic, strategic, and stability benifits that oil provides. Or is the answer in just air attacking sites in the state that sponosors terrorists, and not enganging in a ground war? Do you assasinate foreign leaders? I don't know. My point is that the debate aroudn Iraq isn't was it good v. was it bad, it's not two dimentional. Just as you can't view Israel in should it v. shouldn't it in regards to Lebanon. I get what they did, and mostly support it. However, what all free nations need is a repeatable tool for dealing with terrorists hiding in other nations.
It's not invasion, so what is it?